Haliburton is easily the heel in this scenario. After being voted the most overrated player in the NBA by his peers, Haliburton went on a tear, leading the Pacers to series wins over the Milwaukee Bucks and Cleveland Cavaliers. He’s taken up the mantle passed on by Pacers’ legend Reggie Miller in irking the Knicks fanbase beyond their wits’ end.

The rival guards, who met last year in the East semifinals, with Haliburton's Pacers advancing, appeared on an episode of “SmackDown” at Madison Square Garden in June 2024, feuding alongside Logan Paul and other stars.